'Sunset Boulevard' makes a (stair)case for epic musicals
by Misha Berson
Seattle Times theater critic VANCOUVER,
B.C. - If "Phantom of the Opera" was a musical about a chandelier, then
composer Andrew Lloyd Webber's blockbuster follow-up, "Sunset Boulevard," is a
musical about a swimming pool and an extremely long, gaudy staircase.
Actually, thanks to some splendid source material, the $8
million production of "Sunset Boulevard" making its Northwest debut at the Ford
Centre for the Performing Arts in Vancouver, B.C., occasionally threatens to be something
beyond an excuse for eye-popping scenic effects and a schmaltz-drenched score - though it
has those accoutrements, plus a spectacular staging by an epic-musical-specialist
director, Trevor Nunn.
Like the memorable 1950 film by Billy Wilder which the Don
Black-Christopher Hampton book and lyrics are closely based on, this multiple Tony Award
winning show conveys an opulent noir morality tale set in Hollywood at its most seductive
and perverse. Unlike the movie, however, the stage version sometimes sweetens the acidic
tartness of the fable with the kind of glam-sham romanticism Wilder was slyly sending up.
"Sunset Boulevard" actually has more in common
with Lloyd Webber's highly profitable "Phantom of the Opera" than superior
stagecraft and a penchant for recycling a few overbearing melodies ad infinitum. The
ultra-romantic "Phantom" drummed up sympathy and repulsion for a deformed but
amorous male demon dwelling in the bowels of the Paris Opera House. "Sunset
Boulevard" promotes our love-hate relationship with a movie-queen gorgon hiding out
in a Tinsel Town mansion. These two monsters are flip sides of the same mythic coin - but
"Sunset" is more intelligent nonsense, and offers a rare showcase for mature
stage divas.
In London, the diva playing Norma Desmond was Patti
LuPone, on Broadway it was initially Glenn Close, and in Vancouver it is veteran
actress-singer Diahann Carroll, who also starred in the show's lengthy Toronto run.
At 63, Carroll has a few years on Desmond (who is
allegedly a hopeless has-been at 50) but you would never guess it. She looks altogether
smashing sashaying around in Anthony Powell's to-die-for array of beaded, brocaded,
fur-trimmed gowns and satin turbans. Singing the show's pair of signature narcissistic
ballads, "With One Look" and "As If We Never Said Goodbye," Carroll's
voice remains firm and forceful. And she gives the predatory Norma real allure, along with
an aura of touching fragility.
That is quite different , and less vivid, from Close's
Tony-honored approach. Close (like Gloria Swanson, the movie Norma) created a grotesque,
almost vampiric figure - pathetic in her grasping desire for Joe Gillis, the cynical young
screenwriter whom fate deposits at her lair one night, and sadly delusional in her belief
that mogul director Cecil B. DeMille would soon restore her stardom, yes. But also a
personality so distorted by her years in the Dream Factory that she finally can't
distinguish between playing the murderous Salome and being her.
With Carroll's more vulnerable and sympathetic portrayal,
"Sunset Boulevard" loses much of the morbid campiness at its deliciously wicked
core. Some sense of irony is preserved, however, in Rex Smith's inspired Joe Gillis.
Smith's boyishness-gone-to-seed good looks, his hearty singing voice and his flair for
boisterous self-mockery keep the show from bogging down in melodrama more than once. He
never lets us forget that Joe is striking a Faustian bargain by becoming the script doctor
and boy toy of a rich wacko. And the guilty, cocky shrug he gives, while lolling by
Norma's pool in the snazzy new suit she's bought him, says it all.
The show's two major supporting roles are well-filled.
Walter Charles (known in Seattle for his sterling work at the 5th Avenue Theatre) has the
grim Teutonic efficiency of Norma's butler Max down pat, and sings his heart out in the
worshipful, "The Greatest Star of All." And Anita Louise Combe gives a charming
account of Betty, the wholesome script girl who becomes Norma's unwitting rival.
As for the production enfolding these performers and a
large, busy chorus - well, if it ain't Cecil B. DeMille, it's close. John Napier's mammoth
sets fade in and out to striking montage effect, creating a bipolar Lotus Land: Norma's
absurdly rococo villa (which has enough gilded kitsch bric-a-brac to stock several Las
Vegas casino showrooms), and the equally surreal environs of a Hollywood studio complete
with a fabulously vulgar set for a biblical epic.
Andrew Bridge's lighting scheme features marvellously
spooky shadow effects. And especially in a whiz-bang car chase scene that seamlessly
blends film footage with live action, and a couple of ingenious split-level scenes with
two tiers of action, Bridge's contributions enhance Napier's stunning work - as does the
eerie swimming pool image that opens the show.
And that long, imposing staircase? Carroll's regal ascents
and descents don't exploit its full dramatic potential as a gauge of Norma's sanity. Yet
when Carroll makes her final entrance down it to announce she's "ready for my
close-up, Mr. DeMille," you realize nothing less than the grandiose conveyance Napier
and company have provided will do.